Independent · Inspected · Earned
The standard for exceptional short-term rentals.
Every property is inspected in person by a trained evaluator, held to one standard, and recognized only when the result is earned.
Search by area
Destinations
Browse the Guide destination by destination.
U.S. Virgin Islands
St. John
0 stays
U.S. Virgin Islands
St. Thomas
0 stays
U.S. Virgin Islands
St. Croix
0 stays
New England
Martha’s Vineyard
0 stays
Caribbean
British Virgin Islands
0 stays
Caribbean
Turks & Caicos
0 stays
Caribbean
The Bahamas
0 stays
Caribbean
Anguilla
0 stays
Caribbean
St. Barts
0 stays
Caribbean
Barbados
0 stays
Our methodology
One structured evaluation, applied everywhere.
Each property is assessed in person by a trained evaluator using a multi-point framework. The criteria are the same whether the home is in St. John, Paris, Aspen or Cabo.
How we inspect- 01 Architecture
- 02 Design
- 03 Maintenance
- 04 Amenities
- 05 Service quality
- 06 Guest experience
- 07 Destination relevance
Our commitment to neutrality
Keys cannot be purchased, influenced or requested. They must be earned.
We never charge for consideration, never sell awards, and never allow influence of any kind to shape an evaluation. Every decision is grounded in documented criteria and verified performance.